A formal property valuation report is a detailed document. Beyond the headline figure, it records the property's title, planning controls, condition, market evidence and the assumptions the valuer has made.
If you are relying on a valuation for a family law settlement, a tax calculation or an estate, it is worth understanding what each part of the report says and why it matters.
This guide explains a typical report for a Melbourne or regional Victorian property, with the Victorian details that deserve a second look.
What is a property valuation report?
A valuation report is a professional opinion of value, prepared by a qualified valuer, for a specific purpose and date. It sets out what was valued, the basis of value, the evidence relied on and the reasoning behind the conclusion.
Unlike an agent appraisal or an online estimate, a formal report is prepared to be relied on by named parties and may be examined by solicitors, the ATO, the State Revenue Office or a court.
When you may receive a valuation report
You may need a formal report where:
Assets are being divided in a family law property settlement
Your accountant needs a CGT valuation, such as when a home first became a rental
A property is transferred between related parties and duty is assessed on market value
An executor needs a date-of-death value
An SMSF needs a market value for annual reporting
A property is involved in a dispute or court proceedings
Key sections of a valuation report
1.Instructions and purpose
This names the instructing party, the intended users and the purpose. A report prepared for one purpose may not be suitable for another.
2. Valuation date and inspection date
The valuation date is when the value applies. The inspection date is when the valuer attended. In a retrospective report, the two dates may be years apart.
3.Basis of value
Most reports adopt market value. The report should state the interest valued, such as fee simple with vacant possession, or subject to a lease.
4.Title, zoning and planning
In Victoria, title details are usually shown as a Volume and Folio reference. The report should identify the zone under the local planning scheme and any overlays, such as a Heritage Overlay, Land Subject to Inundation Overlay or Bushfire Management Overlay.
5. Property description
The land and improvements are described, including site area, dwelling type, accommodation, construction, condition and any defects.
6. Market commentary and sales evidence
The valuer comments on local conditions and lists the comparable sales relied on,
explaining how each compares with the subject property.
7. Valuation rationale
This section explains the method used, the adjustments applied and how the final figure was reached.
8. Assumptions, qualifications and reliance
The report lists assumptions and limitations, including who may rely on it. Assumptions that do not match your property's real circumstances should be raised with the valuer.
Victorian details worth checking
For a Melbourne or regional Victorian property, consider whether:
The Volume and Folio reference matches your certificate of title
The zone is correct, for example the Neighbourhood Residential Zone or General Residential Zone
All relevant overlays are identified
Covenants or restrictions on title are noted
For apartments and units, owners corporation fees, special levies and any rectification works are considered
Building permits for extensions and additions are reflected
How to review your valuation report
1. Check the purpose and valuation date
Confirm they match your solicitor's or accountant's instructions.
2. Check the property facts
Review the land area, bedrooms, bathrooms, car parking, outbuildings and improvements.
3. Look atthe sales evidence
Ask whether each sale is genuinely comparable in location, size, condition and timing.
4. Read the assumptions
Identify any assumption that does not reflect your property, such as vacant possession for a tenanted home.
5. Ask the valuer questions
Raise concerns in writing with supporting documents, such as plans, permits or your Section 32 vendor statement.
Valuation report versus other documents
| Document | Prepared by | Purpose | Suitable for legal or tax use |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Formal valuation report
|
Certified Practicing Valuer
|
Independent opinion of market value at a stated
date
|
Yes, for the stated purpose
|
| Agent appraisal |
Real estate agent
|
Indicative selling price, often for a listing
|
Generally no |
| Bank valuation |
Valuer instructed by the lender
|
Indicative selling price, often for a listing
|
Generally no; prepared for the
bank
|
|
Rates notice (CIV and Site Value)
|
Valuer-General
Victoria
|
Statutory value as at 1 January for rates and land
tax
|
No; not prepared for a sale or settlement
|
Example: reading a date-of-death report
Consider an executor administering the estate of a parent who owned a 1960s brick veneer house in Bentleigh East. The estate's accountant asks for a valuation as at the date of death, eighteen months ago, to support estate records and any future CGT calculation.
The report arrives with an inspection date this year and a valuation date at the date of death. That is expected for a retrospective report, but the executor should still check that:
The valuation date is the exact date of death advised by the solicitor or accountant
The property description reflects the house as it was at that date, before the family cleared it, repainted and replaced the carpets
The sales evidence comes from the months around the date of death, not from the current market
The zone and overlays are correctly identified, because a Neighbourhood Residential Zone or General Residential Zone can affect redevelopment potential on a large block
The assumptions explain how the earlier condition was established, such as photographs taken before the clean-up
If any of these points is wrong, the report may not meet the estate's needs, even if the figure looks reasonable.
Red flags to look for
Most reports are carefully prepared, but it is worth raising a question with the valuer if you notice:
An incorrect address, Volume and Folio reference, plan number or land area
A missing outbuilding, second dwelling, pool or permitted extension
Comparable sales that are much older, larger or from a clearly different location
A valuation date that differs from your instructions
A reliance clause naming a party you did not expect, such as a lender
An overlay or covenant you know affects the land that is not mentioned
Assumptions that conflict with what you told the valuer, such as vacant possession for a tenanted home
It is far easier to resolve these points before the report is relied on than afterwards.
Documents to keep with your report
Valuation reports are often needed again years later, especially for CGT, estates or SMSF audits. Keep the report together with:
The letter of instruction or engagement terms
Plans, permits and renovation invoices supplied to the valuer
Photographs of the property at the valuation date
Any questions you asked and the valuer's responses
Settlement, transfer or probate documents for the relevant event
Having the full set in one place makes it simpler for your accountant, solicitor or auditor to rely on the report later.
Frequently asked questions
How long can I rely on a valuation report?
A valuation is current only at its valuation date. If the market or the property changes, or a different date is required, an updated report may be needed.
Why does my report value differ from my CIV?
The CIV is a statutory figure prepared annually for rating, as at 1 January. A market valuation is a property-specific opinion at its own date and for its own purpose.
What does vacant possession mean in my report?
It means the property was valued as if it could be sold without a tenant in place. If the property is leased, check whether that assumption fits your purpose.
Can I share my report with my bank or another party?
Only if the valuer agrees. Reliance is usually restricted to the named parties and stated purpose.
What does "subjectto" mean in a valuation report?
A valuation can be stated "subject to" a condition, such as works being completed, a lease being confirmed or the land being free of contamination. The figure only applies if that condition holds. If it does not, the valuer may need to review the report.
Can one report be used for two purposes?
Sometimes, if both purposes and the reliant parties are named in the instructions and the same date applies. If you expect to need a report for more than one purpose, such as estate administration and CGT, tell the valuer at the outset.
Can I ask questions about a family law valuation?
Generally, yes. In family law matters, parties can usually put written questions to a single expert valuer. Your solicitor can advise on the process.
Need a clear property valuation reportin Melbourne?
If you need a well-documented, independent valuation report for a legal, tax, estate or financial purpose, contact ValueMax Property Valuers for valuations across Melbourne and regional Victoria.